"Our League Will Never be the Same"

Fantasy Trophies that Define Leagues.

Fantasy Trophies Owner, Dave Mitri
See how each trophy is made – 100% in my Brooklyn shop.

FantasyTrophies.com was born in 1993 out of a desire to see my own fantasy football league play for a trophy that truly represented the guys in my league and the way we all feel about fantasy sports. For me, it’s never been about the cash prize at the end of the year. Instead it’s about life long bragging rights and the joy of shoving victory in your buddy’s face. It’s that simple.

A garage in Cleveland is where it all began – over 20 years ago. That’s where I started sculpting a lump of clay into a trophy that has since been called, “the greatest fantasy trophy the world has known.”

Fast forward and you’ll find me now married with 2 kids and operating Fantasy Trophies from a shop in Brooklyn, NY. The location may be different, but the quality and craftsmanship remains the same. Every trophy is hand-made and given the same attention that the very first trophy received all those years ago. Because I know when a trophy is unveiled to a new league the reaction will also be the same as the one my buddies had back in Cleveland.

“Our League was blown away by the craftsmanship and the size. Simply Awesome!”
~ John J. Owner


Handmade Originals – The Armchair Quarterback / The Throwback

Our original and still best selling trophy – The Armchair Quarterback. A more recent addition, The Throwback. Both crowd-pleasers.

The Armchair Quarterback
The Throwback

“This is the best fantasy football trophy on the market – BAR NONE!”
~ Mike P. Commissioner


Annual Trophies – “The Mini’s”

For season champions. Roughly 1/3 the size of the original trophies, because you deserve permanent bragging rights.

For the Fantasy Fans in All of Us

Baseball, basketball, hockey and NASCAR trophies.

Golf Tournament Trophy – “The Mulligan”


The Mulligan Golf Trophy


Customize your Trophy

Names Plates

Name Plates
Each name plate holds the champion name, year and an additional line of custom text.

Title Plates
The perpetual bases hold up to 36 seasons of champions.

“I would sell my left gonad to get my name on our trophy.” ~ Frustrated Owner


100% Handmade in the USA

Every trophy I ship is handmade in my Brooklyn shop. Watch the video to see how it’s done.
How our trophies are made


The Wall of Fame

Thanks to Everyone playing for a FantasyTrophy